Eel Scales – Leeuwenhoek said “I Found Them.” Rabbis Said “No Way!”

Note: All items pictured on this website are in the personal collection of Frank W. Reiser. Please contact me if you wish to discuss displaying the collection at your institution or need additional information about the topic.

Leeuwenhoek, searching for tiny things with his newly built microscope, discovered that eels have scales. When Jews heard of his discovery, they wanted to know, “Does that mean eel is kosher?” 

Eel Scales viewed with polarized light. Antique Microscope Slide
Eel Scales viewed with polarized light. Antique Microscope Slide

Eel Scales, 50x magnification, transmitted light, crossed polarizers with a selenite plate.

Eel Scales, Unknown preparer  A paper-wrapped cardboard slide. Scales teased from an eel’s skin and balsam mounted between two coverslips. Early nineteenth century.

The European eel, Anguilla anguilla, is currently red-listed as a critically threatened species by the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s Endangered Species. The reason is commercial overharvesting. In other words, people have eaten almost all of them all.

According to A Manual of Microscopical Mounting, fish scales for polariscope must be balsam or fluid-mounted (Martin 1872). The author additionally recommends that mucus must be removed from the scales when they are freshly collected. This is because fish slime is extremely difficult to remove without damaging a scale after it has dried. 


Leeuwenhoek found older eels have scales. Does that mean their kosher?

In 1684, Antonie Leeuwenhoek (1632 – 1723), working with a single-lens microscope of his design, discovered scales hidden beneath the epidermal cells buried in the connective tissue layer of an eel’s skin. He drew a finely detailed diagram of the scales and published it, along with a short article, in the Royal Society of London Philosophical Transactions (1684). Leeuwenhoek’s pictures show incredibly accurate detail for having been viewed with such an early instrument. His drawings document the magnification and resolution obtainable with the simple microscopes he built.

  Anatomically, eel scales show a growth pattern termed cycloid, a style associated with the more primitive relatives on the boney-fish branch of the evolutionary tree. Eel scales show concentric rings that Leeuwenhoek, correctly supposed were too abundant to be age-indicating growth rings, such as found in a tree trunk. The finding of tiny scales embedded into the skin but not visible on the surface might seem to be an arcane discovery of interest only to ichthyologists. But this was not so at the time. When Leeuwenhoek published his discovery, it ignited a controversy about religious dietary rules to be argued for centuries afterward. The contentious aspect of the discovery was “Can eel now be considered a kosher food as are the other finfish?”

   During Leeuwenhoek’s time, eels were a vital food for Europeans. Once in a European freshwater eel’s lifetime, they migrate from lakes and rivers into saltwater for spawning. The seasonal migration allows them to be easily netted from European rivers in large numbers. When in season, eels were an inexpensive source of high-quality protein. However, since they were thought to be scaleless fish, eels were not a kosher food. Observant Jews, a significant part of Europe’s population, did not eat eels. Leeuwenhoek’s finding opened up a large market for finfish merchants. Hebrew scholars began reassessing the edibility status of eels regarding kosher dietary laws. After pondering the question, they reasoned that the fish scales the Torah referred to were of a type that could be flaked from a fish while leaving its skin behind. Since the complete removal of an eel’s scales required skinning the fish, its flesh remains non-kosher.

   About eight hundred species of eels dwell in the world’s oceans. They comprise a large taxonomic order within the class of bony fish. But only the freshwater eel family, those found in North American and European waters, possess microscopic scales. All other eel species (moray, conger, electric, etc.) lack scales. Additionally, those that develop scales only do so after the fish has grown eight inches in length. Then the scales can only be revealed by raising up the outside epidermis of an eel’s skin and using dissecting needles to tease through the dermal connective tissue beneath. Viewing with a magnifying glass employing crossed polarizers makes finding the tiny scales an easier task.  Eel scales glow with a characteristic light pattern called St. Andrews Cross when viewed through crossed polarizers. Unfortunately, polarized light in microscopy was unknown to Leeuwenhoek, so his discovery is genuinely remarkable.

Eel skin showing imbedded scales microscope slide
Eel skin with scales. Brown bodies are pigment-containing cells that give an eel its dark-brown color. W. H. Walmsley
W. H. Walmsley, antique slide, section of eel skin showing scales
Thin section of eel skin mounted in Canada balsam by W. H. Walmsley of Philadelphia
How to footnote this page.

Reiser, Frank W. (2022). Eel Scales - Leeuwenhoek said yes, but rabbis ruled “no way!” Searching an Invisible World for its Tiniest Things. Accessed at: https://antiqueslides.net/eel-scales/