Charles F. Conly – Photographer of Theater and the Famous

ml

Note: All items pictured on this website are in the personal collection of Frank W. Reiser. Please contact me if you wish to discuss displaying the collection at your institution or need additional information about the topic.

Charles F. Conly (1846–1892)

As a young man, Conly left his hometown of Milford, Massachusetts, for Boston, envisioning a career on the city’s stage. It did not work out. After continuous rejections from interviews and auditions, dejected and needing cash, he spotted a “Boy Wanted” sign at Warren’s Photographic Studio on Washington Street. Though older than a boy, he applied and was hired at the low salary intended for a youth. He quickly learned the craft of photography and excelled at it. Conly returned to Boston’s theater district as a photographer; with a camera he opened doors his acting career never could. He found success among the rich and famous and soon extended his work to the glamorous world of New York’s Broadway.

Early Conly imprint showing original spelling and Warren studio name
Conly used the original spelling of his surname on his earliest works while still including the name of the studio’s previous owner while building his own reputation.
Standard CDV portrait of an unknown sitter. One of Conly’s earliest works using a plain background.

While Conly advertised photographically based crayon portraits, (photographic enlargements artistically finished with crayon to resembled drawn portraits) his main focus was capturing posed performers in front of hand-painted backgrounds—what he termed illusionist settings. He transformed the studio with hanging backdrop paintings, a prop wardrobe, a solarium of tropical plants, and even paper-maché rock formations. Subjects always appeared in distinct gestures, as if in performance. By the 1890s he also excelled at children’s portraits alongside his theatrical work.

A Study by C. F. Conly – albumen silver print
A Study by C. F. Conly
Albumen silver print mounted on cardboard, 6 × 9 inches, Boston, Massachusetts.

This 1886 cabinet photograph of an unknown young lady was taken on a 6 × 9-inch Stanley sensitized glass dry plate. The contact print was made by J. B. Hunter, an employee of Conly. The title tells us it was taken as a promotional example of the studio’s quality work. Uncommissioned portraits are important to historians of photography because the photographer is able to express a personal vision of the art.

Reverse of Conly cabinet card advertising services including Porcelain Lenograph
Reverse of a Conly cabinet card advertising the studio’s services and address. “Porcelain Lenograph” appears to be a term coined by Conly for a proprietary process (possibly a specialized finish or lightbox tracing). No confirmed examples are currently known.

Conly’s reputation was built through pioneering theatrical photography. In 1885 he used electric lights to photograph the audience at Boston’s Bijou Theater. Despite the difficulty of keeping people still, the experiment succeeded; he presented the attendees with souvenir prints that also served as clever advertising. In December 1890 he photographed Boston’s production of Soudan on its 100th performance. His lens also recorded notable figures including Frederick Douglass and Helen Hunt Jackson.

In 1894, at the age of 46, Conly died from complications of consumption (tuberculosis). His wife, Jane A. Harris, inherited the studio and assumed a managerial role.

Hand-colored Conly cabinet card of an actress with studio props

Typical Conly “illusionist” classical theatrical pose.

Hand-colored albumen-print cabinet card of an unknown actress posed with props from Conly’s studio.

To date, Diamond Dyes is the only advertisement found to run on the verse of a Conly CDV card other than for the services of the studio. 

Back of cabinet card advertising Diamond Color Dye Company
The reverse side carries an advertisement for the Diamond Color Dye Company, historically important for producing a standardized collection of dyes that allowed exact color matching—essentially the Pantone of its day. Learn more about Pantone history.
Conly cabinet card – A Quartette of Tippers from A Straight Tip
A Quartette of “Tippers” in A Straight Tip
The four men are members of the Clipper Quartette, the vocal harmony group that performed specialty numbers in the 1891 musical farce A Straight Tip by John J. McNally (produced by the James T. Powers company and opened at the New Park Theatre, New York). Contemporary accounts identify the group’s members active in the early 1890s as Frank T. Ward (who also was cast as the tramp A. Hardupp Beerbohm in the play), John P. Curran (also cast as the bunco man Bill Katchon), Albert (“Al”) Hart (also cast in dual roles), and W. H. White. The photograph demonstrates Conly’s use of painted backdrops and props kept in his studio for theatrical compositions.
Ghost image of Otis Skinner transferred onto the back of the Tippers card
The Ghost of Otis Skinner

The Ghost Image of Otis Skinner

Otis Skinner (1858–1942) was a prominent American stage actor. In the transferred image he appears costumed as Hajj, the cunning beggar-poet in Edward Knoblock’s 1911 play Kismet (an “Arabian Nights”–style drama set in Baghdad). Skinner originated the role on Broadway, played it for roughly twenty years on stage and tour, and reprised it in the 1920 silent and 1930 sound film versions.

The cabinet card titled “A Quartette of Tippers” was apparently stored for a long time in contact with a portrait of Skinner. Silver salts from the Skinner photograph migrated to the reverse of the Tippers card, creating the faint ghost-like mirror image. Interestingly, Skinner’s signature appears as a negative: the ink itself did not transfer; instead it sealed the silver beneath it, leaving a gap in the ghost image. This indicates the signature was added by hand after the photograph was printed rather than written on the original negative.

The Ghost Is Being Ghosted

A secondary, very faint ghost image of a blonde woman is visible overlying Skinner’s ghost portrait. Unfortunately she is too faint to identify.

These transferred images remind us of the sensitivity of nineteenth-century photographs. Three pictures share their stories through pictorial clues, yet they also underscore the importance of proper storage. Density lost from one card became the ghost on another—evidence of the damage caused by careless contact.

How It Happens
The mechanism for the migration of silver in a photograph to migrate to the back of another placed above it due to slow oxidation of the silver in the original photo. The silver ionizes (Ag⁺) and redeposits on the contacting cardboard. Even under relatively dry room-temperature conditions, the following sequence slowly occurs over decades of close contact:
  1. Oxidation
    Trace oxidants from the paper or cardboard, or sulfur-containing pollutants, slowly convert some of the metallic silver into mobile silver ions:
  2. Migration/diffusion
    The silver ions can move through the albumen or gelatin layer coating the paper. Even in low humidity, a microscopic film of adsorbed moisture is normally present on surfaces. Together with any volatile compounds released by the cardboard, allows the ions to cross the interface to  the other card
  3. Re-deposition
    On the receiving cardboard, the ions are reduced back to metallic silver or react with sulfur compounds to form silver sulfide (Ag₂S). The result is a faint mirror image (ghost image) that matches the original photograph’s density.
The negative appearance of a handwritten signature in the ghost image confirms the hypothesis. The ink locally seals or stabilizes the silver beneath it, preventing ion formation and migration from the covered areas.
 
Bringing the Ghost To Life
The ghost image of Otis Skinner (1858 – 1942) was uploaded to Grok Image and processed by xAI image to produce the restoration below.
 

 

Otis Skinner portrait in costume for the play Kismet .circa 1900
Otis Skinner portrait in costume for the play Kismet .circa 1900

 

How to cite this page:
Reiser, Frank W. (2024). “Charles F. Conly – Photographer of Theater and the Famous.” Available at https://antiqueslides.net/charles-f-conly-photographer/

Reference: Boston Gl

A Directory of Massachusetts Photographers, 1839–1900:

Boston Globe, 15 December 1894 – Obituary of Charles F. Conly